magnify

Earth Unaware by Orson Scott Card and Aaron Johnston

THE PREMISE

Earth Unaware is a prequel to the award winning science fiction novel Ender’s Game. The book essentially sets the scene in detail of what human society is like before the arrival of an alien race and then delves into the first encounter. Earth Unaware is the first book of a trilogy that completely tells the back story to Ender’s Game.

THE GOOD

Most of the scientific detail is intricate enough to feel believable without being so heavy that it encumbers the story. Ender’s Game is one of those books that I fell in love when I was young and still holds a special place in my heart. It’s always a pleasure to go back to that world and maybe that skews my perception of this book a little bit.

THE BAD

After I finished the book I realized there are actually a lot of things that happen just right for the story. Just the right character with just the right back story to make them do just the right thing happens to come on scene at just the right time to make the story flow. Much of the story reeks of this deus ex machina. There is one major exception. There is one plot twist that is so obvious and tedious that I was rolling my eyes waiting for it happen. But, at least this one time it didn’t.

THE BOTTOM LINE

Earth Unaware takes you back into a version of Ender’s universe that makes you feel more homesick than nostalgic. The story starts out fine and gets progressively more forced as it goes. As the first book in a sequel it only tells the first third of a story, which although fine is also completely unnecessary. To me the whole point of having a trilogy is to have three separate stories. This feels more like the first chapter or section of a really long book than it does a book unto its own.

 

11/22/63 by Stephen King

THE PREMISE

11/22/63 is a story about a time traveler who attempts to prevent the assassination of JFK. Jake Epping happens upon a portal that allows him to go back in time to 1958. He can return to his own time but each time he uses the portal any previous changes he’s made to the past are reset. In effect, as the book puts it, each trip back is the first trip. This creates a Groundhogs Day like effect that allows Jake to go back in time, make changes, return to the future to check on the results, and have to option to go back in time again with a clean slate if he’s not happy with the results.

THE GOOD

The story is really well written. I was born in 1977 so the barrier to 1958 for me is more than one of memory. But the verisimilitude is so tangible it pops right out of the book and automatically causes my mind to create associations with dozens of references in my head from that time period from the music to the types of cars to the way that people dressed and spoke.

Time travel has been done to death but this story is just different enough that I didn’t mind the cliché. Besides, the story itself isn’t about time travel. It’s almost more of an excuse for the author to go back to a time in his life and explore the consequences of making choices there. The characters in the story are so vivid and powerful that I found myself missing them, as is common with really good fiction, after I finished the story.

THE BAD

Although the story was written by someone who grew up in the 60’s the main character is of my generation and I felt like there were too many cultural and technological differences that were too easily accepted by Jake. Minorities using different bathrooms from Caucasians and it being improper for a man to stay the night at a woman’s house if they weren’t married are two examples. It’s not that these things aren’t addressed it’s that Jake accepts them too easily and too readily. My mind had a lot of trouble glossing over the differences so quickly though it is entirely possible not everyone from my generation, or even the majority, would have so much trouble accepting and adapting to these differences.

THE BOTTOM LINE

11/22/63 is a great story that flew by on my Kindle to the point where I was sad when the ride was finally over and didn’t even notice that it was twice the length of a normal novel. The only thing that keeps it at four out of five stars is that I found the main character’s assimilation to the past a little too smooth and the book didn’t completely satisfy my appetite for all the possibilities that could come from changing history.